BEEF SCARECROW
Under a Beef Red Sky
When I’m Prime Minister
Kidney Piper
Shivering in the Rain
Secret Wolf
Midnight Bastard
Wish That I Could Sleep
Rodney Normal
Beef Scarecrow
Dawn of the Maggots
Beneath the Beef Blue Sea
Dusk of the Maggots
Michael the Swan
GENERAL INFO
Gary’s third full-length album (or fourth, if you count Glamoronica), from his ill-fated psychedelic
period. His last release until Norman in 2014 and, at the time of writing in March 2024, it remains
his final album.
RECORDING VENUE & DATES
27 Maude Terrace, Walthamstow, Oct 20, 2005 - July 21, 2006
COVER IMAGE
The Beef Scarecrow: one of two childlike paintings I did in 2006, never having painted a picture
since I was about ten years old. It seemed to sum up what I was after. The original CD cover (on
the left, below) frames it in a brown wrap, with lettering reminiscent of the font used on the cover
of The Beach Boys’ Pet Sounds. I wanted to zoom closer in, to really see the paint, when I revised it
for the digital release. I’ve always been torn about whether I should have left the words off the
cover altogether and gone for a much more straightforward full-frontal image like the one below
on the right. But I liked the texture detail of the extreme close-up, and the words gave the image
definition. Still torn though.
As with Face Academy, the CD came with an 8-page inlay booklet, but this time it was mainly just
pictures. The two lyrical quotes in the booklet - “My name is time - I live in a clock” and
“Sometimes I go backwards, but only if you’re mental” are both from an unfinished piece called
Swirling Purple Tripe, which would have been Part 2 of the epic Day of the Maggots suite, if only I’d
had the time to finish it. You might notice the clock in one of the photographs is set to 6.45 - the
time my Edinburgh show started.
2006
LISTEN/BUY
THE MUSIC
Thirteen leftfield comedy rock tracks - mostly but not always what you might call ‘songs’ - strung
together into something which may well be an experimental song cycle about an innocent’s
descent into depravity and delusion. But it might just be a load of tripe. And watch out! Whatever
you’ve already understood Gary Le Strange to be, this is a conscious effort to be the opposite. It is
the Anti-LeStrange.
THE RECORDING PROCESS
I’d already had a year to play with Cubase by the time I started this project, but I was still keenly
aware of my own shortcomings as a music programmer. One of the biggest was my ability to
program drums. Fortunately, a company called Spectrasonics (who already made my favourite
two virtual instruments, Atmosphere and Trilogy) helped me out massively by releasing a
groundbreaking piece of rhythm software called Stylus RMX, allowing me to manipulate live and
pre-programmed grooves into shapes that suited the songs I’d written. This (along with its five
Xpansions) ended up forming the rhythmic backbone of Beef Scarecrow and, in conjunction with
the electric basses from Trilogy and rhythm guitar from Steinberg’s amazing Virtual Guitarist,
pushed Gary’s work further away from electronica towards something that, even though it was
completely programmed on a computer, could only really be called rock.
If this sounds like it suddenly made everything easy, it didn’t. I still had absolutely no training and
no idea what I was doing, and my songwriting ambition completely outstripped my meagre
abilities as a recording artist and producer. I was basically making things up as I went along, using
my tiny, dwindling budget to solve huge creative problems completely on my own. More and more
nights spent drinking and smoking (at the time, I was on about forty Camels a day) as I listened to
the same few seconds of sound over and over again, trying to hammer these songs into vaguely
pleasing forms. Less and less time with friends. Less and less time doing gigs that gave me much-
needed feedback. For almost exactly nine months (with occasional brief breaks to do things like
Out To Lunch), Beef Scarecrow was my life.
None of this protected me from the basic technological limitations of mid-2000s hardware. The PC
I had was top notch for the time, but it wasn’t necessarily capable of running a project with thirty
or forty layers of bass, drums, acoustic and electric rhythm guitar, lead guitar, strings, brass,
woodwinds (all courtesy of East West’s Quantum Leap Symphonic Orchestra), several synth lines,
multiple percussion instruments and stacks of lead and backing vocal takes, each loaded up with
EQ, compression, filters, distortion, reverb and delay. At least not without stuttering and crashing
and generally being rotten to work with. This meant a lot of bouncing down from multiple MIDI
tracks to fewer audio tracks, freeing up more RAM but creating other problems of its own.
Looking back on it, I’m amazed what I managed to get away with. But the whole thing was so over-
ambitious, it led to a kind of sonic maximalism, with way too much going on at once. I thought of
this as Gary’s psychedelic album, but it often lacks the lightness, the fluid dynamics and the sonic
clarity I’d normally associate with British psychedelia. The original 2006 mix in particular was quite
muddy in places, and many of the vocals got lost in the mix: a cardinal sin for comedy songs.
I was aware of this at the time. I would have loved to put it right. But I only had so much time. I
had a show to write and rehearse, and the album had to be ready to sell at my Edinburgh show in
August 2006. In the end, I was working right up to the wire, with the final masters not ready till July
21st. Consequently the CDs didn’t arrive till I was already several days into the show. And then, to
add insult to misery, barely anyone bought them anyway.
When it came to the digital release seven years later, I thought maybe I could fix it. The 2013
remaster is technically a remix rather than a straight remaster, but in such a subtle, shallow way
that calling it a ‘remix’ would have been tantamount to fraud. I wanted to do a full new mix of all
the elements from the ground up, but it quickly became apparent I still didn’t have the skill, the
technology or - most crucially - the time to do it justice. So I opted for a middle-ground option,
increasing the volume of the vocal line relative to the other instruments and slightly brightening
the overall sound. It achieved a lot of what I wanted to achieve - making most of the words clearly
audible while retaining the punch and weight of the backing tracks I’d spent so much time on - but
there’s still quite a long way to go before I’m totally happy.
THOUGHTS & FEELINGS
Stewart Lee once told me he thought this was more a Waen Shepherd album than a Gary Le
Strange project, and I’ve often been tempted to look back and agree with him. But that’s only
because it flopped. The truth is, Gary was always going to do this. It was always on the cards that,
if his career lasted long enough, he’d take a detour down a weird, anti-commercial alley that would
alienate even his staunchest fans. I just saw that as part and parcel of what genuinely good pop
stars did. And this was - at the time - my only chance to do it. If you see this as more Waen than
Gary, that’s presumably because the idea of Gary as an exclusively 80s-inspired character was too
strong, and I underestimated that. But this is absolutely 100% a Gary Le Strange project, and I
shouldn’t have spent most of the past eighteen years regretting that.
Listening to it now, I don’t find much to regret at all. The backing tracks are, without exception, the
best music I’d made up to that point. You could definitely make a good argument to say they’re
the best set of lyrics I’d written as well. The question is whether I managed to marry the music and
the lyrics together effectively to create good songs and good recordings. And I’d absolutely forgive
you if you genuinely think I didn’t. My primitive skills as a studio engineer didn’t allow me to lift
this stuff as high as it needed to go, and often the sounds mash together to create quite a
challenging noise, when a bit more subtlety would have helped. The remaster I did in 2013 went
some way towards correcting that, but it didn’t iron out all the problems.
As for whether they’re good songs, a lot of that is going to be up to you, and whether you find the
general gist of them appealing. They’re certainly different to what I’d done before, though the
deeper you dig, you’ll probably find more similarities than differences. Michael the Swan is a
rewrite of Ballerina. Secret Wolf is Sex Dummy. I just swapped the distant, unattainable objects of
Gary’s early desires for things that were more immediate, more visceral, more meat-based. And
far more perverse.
But on a personal level, I love this stuff. It’s not as great as the stuff Gary did in the mid-2010s, but
it’s by far my favourite of the three albums he made in the 2000s. It’s not readily accessible and it
was murder to sing many of the songs live, but as a thing to listen to, this is basically the only Gary
album I actually enjoy.
The sad thing is that, despite several valiant attempts, I still haven’t been able to follow it up with a
credible full-length fourth effort. I think if I had, Beef Scarecrow would look less like a bizarre
outlier and more like a waypoint on a journey, or just another chapter in a long, long story.
BEST TRACK
Another one where the whole is probably greater than the sum of its parts, the album works best
in its entirety. But I think most people would say Rodney Normal’s the track to listen out for. Other
highlights include Shivering in the Rain, Midnight Bastard, the ten-and-a-half-minute Day of the
Maggots and the album closer Michael the Swan.
--------------------------------------------------
BANDCAMP UPDATE (April 2024)
Beef Scarecrow is arguably the most substantially enhanced album in Gary’s Bandcamp
discography, with around 21 extra minutes of music. The Elemental Remix of Michael the Swan
was originally released as a free download only a couple of months ago on this very site (though
the version on Bandcamp is available in a much higher 24-bit resolution), while the other four
tracks are previously unreleased songs, all written and considered for the original album, but all
rejected for various different reasons.
Oui Monsieur Papillon was recorded in 2005/06 and remastered in 2024 for this release. I always
liked it as a recording in itself, but didn’t think it was funny enough for the album.
Black Doll Man was a live favourite at the time but I only managed to finish the backing track
before the 2006 album release. It just didn’t quite fit into the flow of the album, so it seemed
better to save it for another day. I finally got Gary to record a vocal line in 2013, but didn’t mix it
properly until this year.
Cat in a Washing Machine was one of the earliest songs written for the album and I made several
attempts at a backing track, but didn’t like any of them. Then, when I expanded the spoken
“Mummy” section into Day of the Maggots, it seemed superfluous, so I ditched it. The version here
is a composite made of different bits from four separate demo tracks, spliced together with a
newly-recorded vocal from 2024. Possibly the biggest revelation from this entire project.
Swirling Purple Tripe was originally supposed to be the psychedelic centrepiece of the Maggots
suite, designed to fit between Dawn of the Maggots and Beneath the Beef Blue Sea (a.k.a. Seafood
Medley). I recorded most of it at the time, but this is a new mix, with a new vocal line for the end
section recorded in March 2024. I’m pretty sure the opening narration was supposed to be
bolstered with sound effects and other sonic delights, but I ran out of time and, in the absence of
any memory of what I might have done with it, it seems wisest to just leave it alone. So it’s not
quite what I was trying to achieve in 2006 but it’s pretty close, and if you cue it up between Tracks
10 and 11, you’ll get a broad idea of what I was aiming for.
BONUS TRACKS (BANDCAMP ONLY)
Oui Monsieur Papillon (2024 remaster)
Black Doll Man (2013 vocal, 2024 mix)
Cat in a Washing Machine (2024 vocal)
Swirling Purple Tripe (2024 mix)
Michael the Swan (2024 Elemental Remix)
BEEF SCARECROW
Under a Beef Red Sky
When I’m Prime Minister
Kidney Piper
Shivering in the Rain
Secret Wolf
Midnight Bastard
Wish That I Could Sleep
Rodney Normal
Beef Scarecrow
Dawn of the Maggots
Beneath the Beef Blue Sea
Dusk of the Maggots
Michael the Swan
GENERAL INFO
Gary’s third full-length album (or fourth, if you count
Glamoronica), from his ill-fated psychedelic period.
His last release until Norman in 2014 and, at the
time of writing in March 2024, it remains his final
album.
RECORDING VENUE & DATES
27 Maude Terrace, Walthamstow, Oct 20, 2005 - July
21, 2006
COVER IMAGE
The Beef Scarecrow: one of two childlike paintings I
did in 2006, never having painted a picture since I
was about ten years old. It seemed to sum up what I
was after. The original CD cover (on the left, below)
frames it in a brown wrap, with lettering reminiscent
of the font used on the cover of The Beach Boys’ Pet
Sounds. I wanted to zoom closer in, to really see the
paint, when I revised it for the digital release. I’ve
always been torn about whether I should have left
the words off the cover altogether and gone for a
much more straightforward full-frontal image like
the one below on the right. But I liked the texture
detail of the extreme close-up, and the words gave
the image definition. Still torn though.
As with Face Academy, the CD came with an 8-page
inlay booklet, but this time it was mainly just
pictures. The two lyrical quotes in the booklet - “My
name is time - I live in a clock” and “Sometimes I go
backwards, but only if you’re mental” are both from
an unfinished piece called Swirling Purple Tripe,
which would have been Part 2 of the epic Day of the
Maggots suite, if only I’d had the time to finish it. You
might notice the clock in one of the photographs is
set to 6.45 - the time my Edinburgh show started.
THE MUSIC
Thirteen leftfield comedy rock tracks - mostly but
not always what you might call ‘songs’ - strung
together into something which may well be an
experimental song cycle about an innocent’s descent
into depravity and delusion. But it might just be a
load of tripe. And watch out! Whatever you’ve
already understood Gary Le Strange to be, this is a
conscious effort to be the opposite. It is the Anti-
LeStrange.
THE RECORDING PROCESS
I’d already had a year to play with Cubase by the
time I started this project, but I was still keenly
aware of my own shortcomings as a music
programmer. One of the biggest was my ability to
program drums. Fortunately, a company called
Spectrasonics (who already made my favourite two
virtual instruments, Atmosphere and Trilogy) helped
me out massively by releasing a groundbreaking
piece of rhythm software called Stylus RMX, allowing
me to manipulate live and pre-programmed grooves
into shapes that suited the songs I’d written. This
(along with its five Xpansions) ended up forming the
rhythmic backbone of Beef Scarecrow and, in
conjunction with the electric basses from Trilogy and
rhythm guitar from Steinberg’s amazing Virtual
Guitarist, pushed Gary’s work further away from
electronica towards something that, even though it
was completely programmed on a computer, could
only really be called rock.
If this sounds like it suddenly made everything easy,
it didn’t. I still had absolutely no training and no idea
what I was doing, and my songwriting ambition
completely outstripped my meagre abilities as a
recording artist and producer. I was basically making
things up as I went along, using my tiny, dwindling
budget to solve huge creative problems completely
on my own. More and more nights spent drinking
and smoking (at the time, I was on about forty
Camels a day) as I listened to the same few seconds
of sound over and over again, trying to hammer
these songs into vaguely pleasing forms. Less and
less time with friends. Less and less time doing gigs
that gave me much-needed feedback. For almost
exactly nine months (with occasional brief breaks to
do things like Out To Lunch), Beef Scarecrow was my
life.
None of this protected me from the basic
technological limitations of mid-2000s hardware.
The PC I had was top notch for the time, but it wasn’t
necessarily capable of running a project with thirty
or forty layers of bass, drums, acoustic and electric
rhythm guitar, lead guitar, strings, brass, woodwinds
(all courtesy of East West’s Quantum Leap
Symphonic Orchestra), several synth lines, multiple
percussion instruments and stacks of lead and
backing vocal takes, each loaded up with EQ,
compression, filters, distortion, reverb and delay. At
least not without stuttering and crashing and
generally being rotten to work with. This meant a lot
of bouncing down from multiple MIDI tracks to
fewer audio tracks, freeing up more RAM but
creating other problems of its own.
Looking back on it, I’m amazed what I managed to
get away with. But the whole thing was so over-
ambitious, it led to a kind of sonic maximalism, with
way too much going on at once. I thought of this as
Gary’s psychedelic album, but it often lacks the
lightness, the fluid dynamics and the sonic clarity I’d
normally associate with British psychedelia. The
original 2006 mix in particular was quite muddy in
places, and many of the vocals got lost in the mix: a
cardinal sin for comedy songs.
I was aware of this at the time. I would have loved to
put it right. But I only had so much time. I had a
show to write and rehearse, and the album had to
be ready to sell at my Edinburgh show in August
2006. In the end, I was working right up to the wire,
with the final masters not ready till July 21st.
Consequently the CDs didn’t arrive till I was already
several days into the show. And then, to add insult
to misery, barely anyone bought them anyway.
When it came to the digital release seven years later,
I thought maybe I could fix it. The 2013 remaster is
technically a remix rather than a straight remaster,
but in such a subtle, shallow way that calling it a
‘remix’ would have been tantamount to fraud. I
wanted to do a full new mix of all the elements from
the ground up, but it quickly became apparent I still
didn’t have the skill, the technology or - most
crucially - the time to do it justice. So I opted for a
middle-ground option, increasing the volume of the
vocal line relative to the other instruments and
slightly brightening the overall sound. It achieved a
lot of what I wanted to achieve - making most of the
words clearly audible while retaining the punch and
weight of the backing tracks I’d spent so much time
on - but there’s still quite a long way to go before I’m
totally happy.
THOUGHTS & FEELINGS
Stewart Lee once told me he thought this was more
a Waen Shepherd album than a Gary Le Strange
project, and I’ve often been tempted to look back
and agree with him. But that’s only because it
flopped. The truth is, Gary was always going to do
this. It was always on the cards that, if his career
lasted long enough, he’d take a detour down a weird,
anti-commercial alley that would alienate even his
staunchest fans. I just saw that as part and parcel of
what genuinely good pop stars did. And this was - at
the time - my only chance to do it. If you see this as
more Waen than Gary, that’s presumably because
the idea of Gary as an exclusively 80s-inspired
character was too strong, and I underestimated that.
But this is absolutely 100% a Gary Le Strange
project, and I shouldn’t have spent most of the past
eighteen years regretting that.
Listening to it now, I don’t find much to regret at all.
The backing tracks are, without exception, the best
music I’d made up to that point. You could definitely
make a good argument to say they’re the best set of
lyrics I’d written as well. The question is whether I
managed to marry the music and the lyrics together
effectively to create good songs and good
recordings. And I’d absolutely forgive you if you
genuinely think I didn’t. My primitive skills as a
studio engineer didn’t allow me to lift this stuff as
high as it needed to go, and often the sounds mash
together to create quite a challenging noise, when a
bit more subtlety would have helped. The remaster I
did in 2013 went some way towards correcting that,
but it didn’t iron out all the problems.
As for whether they’re good songs, a lot of that is
going to be up to you, and whether you find the
general gist of them appealing. They’re certainly
different to what I’d done before, though the deeper
you dig, you’ll probably find more similarities than
differences. Michael the Swan is a rewrite of
Ballerina. Secret Wolf is Sex Dummy. I just swapped
the distant, unattainable objects of Gary’s early
desires for things that were more immediate, more
visceral, more meat-based. And far more perverse.
But on a personal level, I love this stuff. It’s not as
great as the stuff Gary did in the mid-2010s, but it’s
by far my favourite of the three albums he made in
the 2000s. It’s not readily accessible and it was
murder to sing many of the songs live, but as a thing
to listen to, this is basically the only Gary album I
actually enjoy.
The sad thing is that, despite several valiant
attempts, I still haven’t been able to follow it up with
a credible full-length fourth effort. I think if I had,
Beef Scarecrow would look less like a bizarre outlier
and more like a waypoint on a journey, or just
another chapter in a long, long story.
BEST TRACK
Another one where the whole is probably greater
than the sum of its parts, the album works best in its
entirety. But I think most people would say Rodney
Normal’s the track to listen out for. Other highlights
include Shivering in the Rain, Midnight Bastard, the
ten-and-a-half-minute Day of the Maggots and the
album closer Michael the Swan.
--------------------------------------------------
BANDCAMP UPDATE (April 2024)
Beef Scarecrow is arguably the most substantially
enhanced album in Gary’s Bandcamp discography,
with around 21 extra minutes of music. The
Elemental Remix of Michael the Swan was originally
released as a free download only a couple of
months ago on this very site (though the version on
Bandcamp is available in a much higher 24-bit
resolution), while the other four tracks are
previously unreleased songs, all written and
considered for the original album, but all rejected
for various different reasons.
Oui Monsieur Papillon was recorded in 2005/06 and
remastered in 2024 for this release. I always liked it
as a recording in itself, but didn’t think it was funny
enough for the album.
Black Doll Man was a live favourite at the time but I
only managed to finish the backing track before the
2006 album release. It just didn’t quite fit into the
flow of the album, so it seemed better to save it for
another day. I finally got Gary to record a vocal line
in 2013, but didn’t mix it properly until this year.
Cat in a Washing Machine was one of the earliest
songs written for the album and I made several
attempts at a backing track, but didn’t like any of
them. Then, when I expanded the spoken “Mummy”
section into Day of the Maggots, it seemed
superfluous, so I ditched it. The version here is a
composite made of different bits from four separate
demo tracks, spliced together with a newly-recorded
vocal from 2024. Possibly the biggest revelation
from this entire project.
Swirling Purple Tripe was originally supposed to be
the psychedelic centrepiece of the Maggots suite,
designed to fit between Dawn of the Maggots and
Beneath the Beef Blue Sea (a.k.a. Seafood Medley). I
recorded most of it at the time, but this is a new mix,
with a new vocal line for the end section recorded in
March 2024. I’m pretty sure the opening narration
was supposed to be bolstered with sound effects
and other sonic delights, but I ran out of time and, in
the absence of any memory of what I might have
done with it, it seems wisest to just leave it alone. So
it’s not quite what I was trying to achieve in 2006 but
it’s pretty close, and if you cue it up between Tracks
10 and 11, you’ll get a broad idea of what I was
aiming for.
BONUS TRACKS (BANDCAMP ONLY)
Oui Monsieur Papillon (2024 remaster)
Black Doll Man (2013 vocal, 2024 mix)
Cat in a Washing Machine (2024 vocal)
Swirling Purple Tripe (2024 mix)
Michael the Swan (2024 Elemental Remix)